Sotheby’s Wine NY is delighted to continue its autumn sale series with “Vine | A Fine West Coast Cellar,” which charts the high points of Burgundy, Bordeaux, the Rhône, Spain and Napa. Leading the sale is a compelling selection of Burgundy, featuring DRC, Leroy, Comte Liger-Belair, and JF Mugnier, followed by parcel-quantities of top-class Bordeaux, in a variety of formats, focusing on the region’s excellent 2005 vintage. Rayas and Vega Sicilia carry the flag for the Rhône and Spain, respectively, and Napa is well represented by Harlan, Bond, Colgin, and parcel quantities of Silver Oak.
Anchoring the sale are 180+ lots celebrating the great 2005 Bordeaux vintage, featuring top-class chateaux, including first growths, “super seconds,” and right-bank equivalents, many available in parcel quantities.
- LAFITE 2005
- LATOUR 2005
- MOUTON ROTHSCHILD 2005
- MARGAUX 2005
- MONTROSE 2005
- COS D’ESTOURNEL 2005
- PICHON LALANDE 2005
- PICHON BARON 2005
- GRAND PUY LACOSTE 2005
- LEOVILLE LAS CASES 2005
- DUCRU BEAUCAILLOU 2005
- CHEVAL BLANC 2005
- ANGELUS 2005
- PAVIE 2005
-
LAFITE 2005Great, warm, spicy nose. Big, huge, massive rich wine. An absolute 'must have', combining the enormous breed of Lafite with depth and profundity. Great, long, cassis finish. A giant, in all senses of the word.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA95 -
LATOUR 2005Huge plums and roses nose. So silky-textured but with great flesh and body. Irony and tannic in the Latour way but with wonderful red fruits and freshness to balance.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 98 -
MOUTON ROTHSCHILD 200585% Cabernet Sauvignon, 14% Merlot, 1% Cabernet Franc. In 2019, this is spectacular, fresh and with a huge life ahead, but already ultra enjoyable to taste, in that ripe cassis way. Great structure and harmony, developing all the dimensions almost as one drinks - as one does.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
Label Artist: Giuseppe Penone
WA 97 -
MARGAUX 2005A fascinating mineral and charcoal nose. Meaty and rosy on the palate with flavours of wild herbs and great youth.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 98+ -
MONTROSE 2005The last vintage of Jean-Louis Charmolue before he sold the property and what a tribute to him. At the château, a huge, all-enveloping nose, cedars and cigars. Fabulous and flavoury on the palate, with both softness and crispness. Winey beauty, with that 'marine' touch. Will it be another 1990? It will certainly keep for decades more.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 94+ -
COS D’ESTOURNEL 2005Coffee beans and raspberries on the nose. Great explosion of fruit on the palate, the natural concentration of this vintage. Super silky texture and a huge blackcurrant taste and heart to it. Very elegant and very fine.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 97 -
PICHON LALANDE 2005A wonderful, even 'Burgundian' nose. A wine of great composition on the palate, still with that youthful 2005 verve, with lots of meaty fruit and structure. You can forget this for a bit, if so inclined.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW -
PICHON BARON 2005Purple damson colour. Big Pauillac style - comparisons with Pontet Canet. The sheer health of the vintage bursts out of the glass. Pronounced acidity and big shoulders. Tight-knit at four years old. Cassis finish. A big, sturdy wine that needs decades to hone down.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW -
GRAND PUY LACOSTE 2005In 2015, this has a terrific, emphatic nose of Grand Pauillac, full of cassis splendour. A luscious, powerful mouthful, immensely satisfying, very classy and long on the finish.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW -
LEOVILLE LAS CASES 2005Real finesse on the nose although it is tight and concentrated at this early stage. Lovely vanillin and berries, plus the great breed and class of the château. The tannins have huge polish.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 97+ -
DUCRU BEAUCAILLOU 2005This is truly top flight in every sense of the word. Complex, aromatic and noble bouquet, with massive, healthy fruit. Stunning opulence, freshness and all-enveloping fruit on the palate. Silky redcurrants. Really luscious and long - bingo!
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 97 -
CHEVAL BLANC 2005Very spicy nose with a real coffee taste. Very classic in structure, without excessive extraction which is not their style. They prefer to bring out the freshness to balance the richness. Silky, harmonious and so 'clean'. So fresh, with so much fruity attack. Meaty and so lively.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 100 -
ANGELUS 2005A truly "classic" nose of frank fruit, many-layered and with multi-dimensional scent. Violets and raspberries. A terrific mouthful of red fruit - reaches all the corners. This is harmony in action, with that perfect balance of fruit, acidity and tannin. Volume and length. Suave and sweet. This truly represents the vintage in all its glory.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 100 -
PAVIE 2005A wonderfully vibrant nose. A real liquorice and cherries taste. The perfect structure of 2005. Finish of blackcurrants. A total "keeper".
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
WA 100
The Domaine, as it is known, is iconic. Much more important, it also produces the most extraordinary wines in Burgundy - and it has been doing so for a long time. The generations responsible for the Domaine change, but the terroir remains. And these are very special vineyard parcels indeed, married to meticulous care and philosophy leading to low yields and healthy, ripe grapes, at whatever cost. From the 1990s, vineyard policy has been organic, with co-owner Aubert de Villaine monitoring everything with his usual attention to detail. Domaine de la Romanée-Conti wines evolve and develop dimensions in a way that resembles a mosaic – points of bouquet and flavor making up a harmonious whole that becomes more beautiful as it unfolds in the glass. Yes, these are hedonistic wines and yes, they are not like any other. The trick is in capturing what these remarkable plots of vines can give and letting them express themselves through minimum intervention and enlightened nurturing.
– SERENA SUTCLIFFE, MW
A formidable name with which to conjure in the Northern Rhône. Marcel and Philippe Guigal are a brilliant combination and the heavenly trio of great Côte Rôtie wines, La Turque, La Landonne and La Mouline, bear witness to their talent. These wines capture that elusive combination of power, depth of flavour and harmony, amazingly created from very long aging in 100 percent new oak. But wines of such substance and individuality can take it. La Mouline emerges from the Côte Blonde of Côte Rôtie, La Turque and La Landonne from the Côte Brune, but La Landonne contains no white Viognier grapes amongst the Syrah. There is little in the wine world to equal a comparison between these three magisterial wines.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
Vega Sicilia is a name that resounds throughout the world, a vinous flagship for its country and a landmark for serious wine collectors everywhere. The wine is a true reflection of its region, climate and the area's oenological traditions. Ribera del Duero, with its affinity with the Tempranillo grape, its high altitude and its hot days and cold nights, is one of the world's classic wine regions. These treasures are part of Spain's patrimony and shining examples of what can be achieved when terroir and dynamism meet.
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW
This is quintessential California Cabernet Sauvignon for me, whether it is Alexander Valley or Napa. The wines are emphatic, rich and redolent of the American oak barrels in which they are matured. The spicy black fruit has overtones of mint, cocoa and Russian leather, all of which is extremely attractive! The Alexander Valley wines are scrumptious and ready a little earlier than the complex Napa Valley version. Recently, winemaker Daniel Baron put on an amazing vertical tasting of both wines when I visited the winery and I found the quality superbly consistent. The pleasure factor is high and the wines highly gulpable – they cry out for steak!
– Serena Sutcliffe, MW