Lot 63
  • 63

EINSTEIN, ALBERT. AUTOGRAPH MANUSCRIPT ON HIS FAMOUS APHORISM "SUBTLE IS THE LORD, MALICIOUS HE IS NOT." 1954

Estimate
10,000 - 15,000 USD
Log in to view results
bidding is closed

Description

Autograph manuscript signed ("A. Einstein"), 1 pp, (8 1/2 x 11 in) in black ink, written on a typed letter signed from Walter Corty to Einstein, in response to Corty's letter, dated October 30, 1954. Together with original cover. Creases where previously folded. 

Catalogue Note

EINSTEIN CONFIRMS THE TRUE FORM OF ONE OF HIS BEST KNOWN AHORISMS, "SUBTLE IS THE LORD, BUT MALICIOUS HE IS NOT. ("Raffiniert ist der Herr Gott, aber boshaft ist er nicht") Einstein writes in response to a Mr. Walter Corty seeking clarification on the original version of Einstein's famous aphorism, which Einstein said while on a visit to Princeton in 1921. Corty had heard two different versions, "God is sophisticated, but not malicious", and "The Lord is subtle, but he is not simply mean". Einstein immediately pens his response directly onto Corty's letter, additionally crossing out the "sophisticated" in Corty's letter and replacing with "subtle", as well as the "simply" in "simply mean". Einstein's response in German in part:

"Gott macht es was schwer, aber bösartig ist er nicht." [God makes it somewhat difficult, but he is not malicious]. He continues "Mündliche Bemerkung, die in scherzhafter Form die Interpretation gewisser physikalischen Experimente anzweifelt.-A. Einstein" [Trans: Here’s an aside about that saying – In a funny way it questions the interpretation of certain physical experiments.]