Jean-François Millet

Mme. J. F. Millet (and sold, her estate, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, April 24-25, 1894, lot 11)
Félix Gérard (acquired at the above sale)
Artemis Gallery, London
American Private Collector (and sold, Christie's, New York, May 5, 1998, lot 32, illustrated)
Acquired at the above sale

Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, Jean-François Millet, March-July 1984, no. 152

Etienne Moreau-Nélaton, Millet raconté par lui-même, Paris, 1921, vol. III, p. 97, 104, 125
Robert L. Herbert, Jean-François Millet, exh. cat., Grand Palais, Paris, 1975, p. 292

The following condition report was kindly provided by Alvarez Fine Art Services, Inc.: Overall this charcoal and chalk on cotton canvas is in very good condition. The cotton canvas is stretched over original wooden stretcher and does not present any tears or losses. Exposure to humidity over time has caused minor scalloping in three of the four corners which is not disturbing. Some tape residues are present around the edges of the stretcher. Visually, the cotton canvas is mildly oxidized from contact with acidic material and a natural process of aging due to light exposure. Otherwise, the pigments appear to be rich and undisturbed.
"This lot is offered for sale subject to Sotheby's Conditions of Business, which are available on request and printed in Sotheby's sale catalogues. The independent reports contained in this document are provided for prospective bidders' information only and without warranty by Sotheby's or the Seller."

Hunting Birds by Torchlight is one of the last works of Jean-François Millet, the under-drawing of an unfinished painting transformed by the dying artist into an astonishing creation of singular intensity.  The composition of Hunting Birds by Torchlight records an event that had been buried in Millet’s memory since his childhood in Normandy, some fifty years before; but it is the gestural force with which Millet pulled his figures out of a swirl of light and energy that gives the work such emotional power.

From William Low, a young American painter who visited Millet in his Barbizon studio during 1873-1874, we learn that Hunting Birds by Torchlight (along with the related painting, Bird's-Nesters, 1874, Philadelphia Museum of Art, which reverses the composition, fig. 1) depicts a scene out of the artist’s early childhood on the Cotentin coast of Normandy.  Millet spoke to Low of going out at night with other peasants of his tiny Gruchy hamlet to hunt the flocks of wild pigeons that migrated across the Channel.  Carrying great torches to blind the startled birds, and swinging heavy clubs to stun them, the older men brought down the pigeons which children scrambling on the ground gathered up into sacks.  For peasants living a hard existence, this communal hunt was one of the few sources of meat in a limited diet.

Without Low’s testament for McClure’s Magazine (May 1896), it would be very difficult to know what to make of Hunting Birds by Torchlight. The maelstrom of flickering torches, waving clubs, and spinning hunters is quite unlike anything else in the solid, stable rural world of Millet’s art.  For thirty-five years he had struggled to adapt traditional French artistic values emphasizing sculptural forms and clear narrative unity to the untraditional subjects of French peasant life.  And side by side with Hunting Birds by Torchlight, Millet worked as well on the monumental Haystacks of The Metropolitan Museum of Art during the last months of his life.  Yet in Hunting Birds, the certainties and spatial clarity of those works are set aside for an impenetrable space of shifting light and shadow in which two archetypal Millet subjects, the hard-working peasant and the beautiful birds of the field, come into direct and uneven conflict.  As he faced his own death, Millet raged against the inevitability of fate and the blindness that commands so many of man’s actions.

Millet worked out the positions of the figures in numerous small pen and ink sketches (coll. Cabinet des dessins, The Louvre, Paris; and others now lost) and in two fuller pencil and crayon compositions (Indianapolis Museum of Art and the London art market, 1980s) that record the fury with which Millet slashed in the flickering light of the background.  Another under-drawing on canvas shows the figures in a smaller, more compact space.

We would like to thank Alexandra R. Murphy for confirming the authenticity of this lot and for writing this catalogue entry.