Antwerp school, circa 1515-1520

Collection of the Grand Duke of Tuscany, Florence (according to the Stillwell catalogue);
Hart, New York, (as by Dürer);
Dr. John E. Stillwell, New York;
His sale, New York, Anderson Galleries, December 1, 1927, lot 232 for $2,000 (as by Joachim Patinir) to Kleinberger;
With Kleinberger Gallery, New York, by whom sold, December 4, 1927, to the Albright Art Gallery (with income from the Charles Clifton Fund), inv. no. 27:43.  

Buffalo, New York, the Buffalo Fine Arts Academy, the Albright Art Gallery, An exhibition of paintings and sculpture added to the permanent collections of the Buffalo Fine Arts Academy through the Generosity of the late Colonel Charles Clifton, November 21-December 16, 1928, cat. no. 7 (as Joachim Patinir);
New York, Kleinberger Galleries, Loan Exhibition of Flemish Primitives in Aid of the Free Milk Fund for Babies, Inc., 1929, pp. 153 - 155, cat. no. 50, illustrated p. 155 (as Joachim Patinir). 

Buffalo, New York, The Buffalo Fine Arts Academy, the Albright Art Gallery, An exhibition of paintings and sculpture added to the permanent collections of the Buffalo Fine Arts Academy through the Generosity of the late Colonel Charles Clifton, exhibition catalogue,
p. 16, cat. no. 7(as Joachim Patinir);
H.G. Sperling, Catalogue of a Loan Exhibition of Flemish Primitives
in Aid of the Free Milk Fund for Babies, exhibition catalogue, pp. 153-54, cat. no. 7 (as by Patinir, with a preface by Max J. Friedländer);
Blue Book, Albright Art Gallery, 1931, p.56 (as by Joachim Patinir);
A. C. Ritchie, Catalogue of the Paintings and Sculpture in the Permanent Collection, p. 210, cat. no. 174 (as School of Joachim Patinir);
S. A. Nash, Albright-Knox Art Gallery, Painting and Sculpture from Antiquity to 1942, New York 1979, p. 164 (as early 16th century, Flemish).