- 213
Circle of Annibale Carracci
Description
- Annibale Carracci
- Christ and the Woman of Canaan
- oil on canvas, unframed
Provenance
R.S.D. Mcnally, by whom sold, London, Christie's, 26 July 1884, lot 84 (as A. Carracci), to Bomfield;
Anonymous sale, London, Phillips,4 July 2000, lot 128, where acquired by the present owner for £32,000.
Catalogue Note
The painting is of almost identical size to the inner sight of the frame (257.5 by 202 cm.) for the altarpiece of this subject commissioned from Annibale Carracci by Cardinal Odoardo Farnese in 1595-97. The picture was intended for the private chapel in the Palazzo Farnese in Rome where the frame, bearing the Farnese coat-of-arms, still remains in situ (see C. Dempsey, "Annibale Carracci's Christ and the Canaanite woman", in The Burlington Magazine, February 1981, pp. 91-5). Annibale's altarpiece remains untraced, though numerous copies exist and scholars have long argued over potential identifications; none of them being entirely convincing due to the discrepancy in the dimensions of the paintings and the inner measurements of the frame.
The composition was to be one of Annibale's most famous and is described in contemporary sources - the biographer Malvasia referred to it as the "Cananea famosa" - and it was engraved numerous times (see Annibale Carracci e i suoi incisori, Rome 1986, pp. 59-62, cat. nos. 1-6). Bellori also described it at great length for it was the first commission Annibale received from the influential Cardinal. The original, which we know began showing signs of distress early on, was later recorded in the Farnese home in Parma, the Palazzo del Giardino, where a room was even named after it ("Camera della Cananea"; see G. Campori, Raccolta di cataloghi ed inventari inediti, Modena 1870, p. 217). After this, the painting's whereabouts remain unknown though it is possible that the painting travelled to Naples in 1734, along with other Farnese property.
Another version of the composition, measuring 260 by 168 cm., is in the Musée des Beaux-Arts, Dijon: this had been erroneously put forward as the lost original by E. Borea and was, more recently, tentatively identified as the painting formerly in the collection of Lucien Bonaparte (see D. Posner, Annibale Carracci. A Study in the Reform of Italian Painting around 1590, London 1971, vol. II, pp. 37-8, cat. no. 87, reproduced). Another version, measuring 255 by 196 cm., formerly in the Palazzo Comunale in Palma and on deposit with the Museo Nazionale di Capodimonte, Naples (inv. SG 6 E), was instead put forward as the lost original by Charles Dempsey (op. cit.).