Numerous halberd blades were discovered and collected in the Huai Valley areas of Anhui and Jiangsu by Orvar Karlbeck and others, many of which found their way into Western collections. See a closely related halberd blade cast with a feline surmounting a bird and of a slightly larger size, from the David David-Weill Collection, sold in our Paris rooms, 16th December 2015, lot 36; and another, included in the exhibition "Animal style" Art from East to West, Asia House Gallery, New York, 1970, cat. no. 65. See also an example from the Stoclet Collection, published in Otto Kümmel, Jörg Trübner zum Gedächtnis. Ergebnisse seiner letzten Chinesischen Reisen, Berlin, 1929, pl. 24; and H.F.E. Visser, Asiatic Art, New York, 1948, pl. 40, no. 49; one in the Museum of Five Continents, Munich, illustrated in Xueqin Li and Sarah Allan, Chinese Bronzes: A Selection from European Collections, Beijing, 1995, pl. 130; and another in the Guimet Museum, Paris, illustration in Xueqin Li and Sarah Allan, ibid., pl. 131. Halberd blades of this type are also known to have been excavated in Shanxi province, such as one excavated in Miaoqian village, Wanrong county, Shanxi province, in 1961, published in Shanxi chutu wenwu [Cultural relics excavated in Shanxi], Shanxi, 1980, pl. 93.